Which massage hurts the most? Five types compared – NAIPO Skip to content 10% off with code BLOG10The right massage device

Cart

Your cart is empty

Where would you like to start?

Popular right now

Article: Which massage hurts the most? Five types compared

Ratgeber5 min read

Which massage hurts the most? Five types compared

In short

Rolfing and targeted trigger point therapy are usually the most intense, closely followed by deep tissue massage. Thai massage and sports massage come next, but depending on the therapist they can be just as firm. A deep, pulling pressure that you can calmly breathe through is normal. Stabbing, electric or radiating pain, tingling and dizziness are reasons to stop immediately.

Show table of contents
Click here to read the full article for free
DisplayRelated offers for the article ‘Which massage hurts the most? Five types compared’
Display

How much a massage hurts depends less on its name than on the person giving it and on the state of your tissue that day. Even so, some techniques are built to put more pressure on a smaller area. Here are five types ranked by typical intensity, along with the line between intense and harmful. What is normal the day after is covered separately in Pain after a massage.

The ranking: from very intense to firm

The order describes how a typical session goes. A gentle Rolfer can hurt less than a heavy-handed sports therapist.

  1. Rolfing: Rolfing is a form of Structural Integration and works on the fascia, not on the muscle alone. The therapist uses knuckles, forearms and elbows, working slowly and deeply. Many people describe the sensation as burning or strong stretching. Traditionally, Rolfing is done as a series of ten sessions.
  2. Trigger point therapy: The therapist presses on a single hardened point in the muscle and holds the pressure, often for 30 to 90 seconds. The pain is pinpoint and can spread to another area, for example from the shoulder blade into the arm. Once the pressure eases, this spreading sensation usually disappears straight away. How to treat such points yourself is explained in Releasing trigger points yourself.
  3. Deep tissue: Slow strokes with a lot of pressure, often with the forearm or elbow, along entire muscle groups. The pain is broader and duller than with a trigger point, but it lasts for the whole session.
  4. Thai massage: Pressure with thumbs, palms, knees and feet, combined with passive stretches. It is usually the stretches that hurt, not the pressure. Why that is explained in Why does Thai massage hurt?, and a rating on a scale is given in How painful is Thai massage?
  5. Sports massage: Firm but functional. Before a competition it is short and light; on rest days it can go deeper. Whether it helps with muscle soreness is covered in Does massage help with muscle soreness?

For comparison: a classic massage sits well below these. Which types cover the whole body is shown in Which massage covers the whole body?

Why the same massage hurts one time and not the next

  • First appointment: Tissue that is not used to it reacts more sensitively. People who go regularly often find the same pressure more pleasant.
  • How you feel on the day: After little sleep, a lot of stress or hard training, your pain threshold is lower.
  • Communication: Many therapists ask for a number from 1 to 10. Say beforehand where your limit is, for example at 6. A good team adjusts the pressure without arguing.

What the studies say: does more pain bring more benefit?

We found no evidence for the common belief that a massage works better the more it hurts. The research is thin and tends to favour a middle ground.

A 2010 review compared studies that tested light against moderate pressure. In adults, stress only fell under moderate pressure. In a small study of 59 people with chronic lower back pain, pain on a scale from 0 to 100 fell from around 58 to 42 after two weeks of deep tissue massage. There was no group without any treatment, so the findings are limited.

There are hardly any robust studies on Rolfing. In a pilot study of 46 people with lower back pain, Structural Integration added to rehabilitation did not reduce pain significantly, but slightly improved limitations in daily life. Side effects were not more frequent. A review of the years 2003 to 2013 found 40 reports of 138 adverse events after massage, including slipped discs, nerve damage and tears in the vertebral arteries of the neck. Forceful, jerky manipulation of the spine was repeatedly involved. Overall, such events are rare.

The free article continues below ↓
Display

When pain is a warning sign

Good massage pain is dull, you can keep breathing calmly, and it eases as soon as the pressure is gone. Stop the session immediately and say stop if any of these occur:

  • stabbing, cutting or electric pain,
  • tingling or numbness in your arms, hands, legs or feet,
  • pain that radiates and stays even without pressure,
  • dizziness, nausea, problems with your vision or a headache during neck work,
  • pain directly on the bone or in the joint rather than in the muscle,
  • you find yourself holding your breath or tensing against the pressure.

The back of the knee, the groin, the front of the neck and varicose veins should not be put under strong pressure. If you have a fresh injury, take blood thinners, have osteoporosis, are pregnant or have had a thrombosis, speak to your doctor first. If pain lasts longer than three days after the massage, gets worse, or a calf swells up, have it checked by a doctor.

Keeping the intensity in your own hands

If you like firm pressure but want to set the limit yourself, there are two ways. With massage guns you start at home on the lowest setting and keep away from bones and the neck. The basic rules are explained in How to use a massage gun correctly.

At the NAIPO Relax Lounge in Hamburg, a massage chair does the work instead of a person. The team sets the programme and intensity together with you before the start. If it is too much, just say so and the setting will be changed. This is no substitute for therapy, but it shows you how much pressure suits you.

Frequently asked questions

Is it normal for a massage to hurt?

With firm techniques, yes, as long as the pain is dull and bearable and eases as soon as the pressure is gone. Anything beyond that, speak up straight away.

Does a massage have to hurt to work?

No. The studies tend to favour moderate rather than maximum pressure. A massage you tense up against misses its purpose.

What do I do if the massage is too firm?

Say so straight away, ideally with a number: that is an 8, please bring it down to a 5. On a massager or massage chair, choose a lower setting or a gentler programme.

Sources

  • Field T, Diego M, Hernandez-Reif M (2010): Moderate pressure is essential for massage therapy effects. International Journal of Neuroscience. doi:10.3109/00207450903579475
  • Majchrzycki M, Kocur P, Kotwicki T (2014): Deep tissue massage and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs for low back pain: a prospective randomized trial. The Scientific World Journal. doi:10.1155/2014/287597
  • Jacobson EE, Meleger AL, Bonato P et al. (2015): Structural integration as an adjunct to outpatient rehabilitation for chronic nonspecific low back pain: a randomized pilot clinical trial. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. doi:10.1155/2015/813418
  • Yin P, Gao N, Wu J, Litscher G, Xu S (2014): Adverse events of massage therapy in pain-related conditions: a systematic review. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. doi:10.1155/2014/480956

This article is not a substitute for medical advice.

Display

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

All comments are moderated before being published.

Ad · Our picks on Amazon“Which massage hurts the most?”

Read more

Massage knowledge

Sports massage: procedure, effects and what it cannot do

Short answer: A sports massage is a firm massage focused on the muscles that have been worked, short and stimulating before a competition, calmer and longer afterwards. It eases muscle soreness and...

Read more
Massage knowledge

Headaches and massage: what the studies really show

Short answer: A neck and shoulder massage can feel good if you have tension-type headaches. In studies, the main change was that the muscles became less tender, and many people felt their headaches...

Read more